Nontraditional

Engagement Rings

Pop the question with a ring that’s as unique as your sweetheart. Our meticulously crafted nontraditional engagement rings feature recycled metals and unusual gemstones, including champagne, black, and grey diamonds. These stunning pieces go beyond traditional, classic designs and can be personalized so they are as unique as the wearer.

Nontraditional

Engagement Rings

Pop the question with a ring that’s as unique as your sweetheart. Our meticulously crafted nontraditional engagement rings feature recycled metals and unusual gemstones, including champagne, black, and grey diamonds. These stunning pieces go beyond traditional, classic designs and can be personalized so they are as unique as the wearer.

Best Seller

A three stone engagement ring with a round shape black diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold
Angled view of a three stone engagement ring with a round shape black diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold
Side view of a three stone engagement ring with a round shape black diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold
A three stone engagement ring with a round shape white diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in yellow gold stacked above a 7 diamond curve band on a lighter-complexion left hand ring finger., White Gold, Rose Gold, Yellow Gold
A three stone engagement ring with a round shape black diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in rose gold stacked above a small 7 white diamond curve band in rose gold., White Gold, Rose Gold, Yellow Gold

Hazeline Three Stone Ring

14k Gold & Black Diamond (1.00ct)

$5,450.00

A three stone engagement ring with a round shape black diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in rose gold stacked above a small 7 white diamond curve band in rose gold.

Hazeline Suite No. 11

starting at $6,600.00

A three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape brilliant cut 1.00ct white diamond center stone with two white diamond trillion side stones set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold
Side view of a three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape brilliant cut 1.00ct white diamond center stone with two white diamond trillion side stones set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold
A three stone engagement ring with a 1.25ct marquise shape white diamond center stone with two white diamond trillion side stones set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold

Marquise Bea Ring

14k Gold & White Diamond

starting at $12,050.00

A ring with a hexagonal shaped black diamond center stone with one baguette black diamond and one white diamond trillion on either side set in yellow gold.
Side view of a ring with a hexagonal shaped black diamond center stone with one baguette black diamond and one white diamond trillion on either side set in yellow gold.

Theda Hex Ring

Yellow Gold & Black Diamond & Grey Diamond (3.13ct)

Most Loved

A three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape 1.25ct black diamond center stone with two white diamond trillion side stones set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold

Marquise Bea Ring

14k Gold & Black Diamond (1.25ct)

$6,100.00

A band with white diamonds in ascending size set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold
A band with white diamonds in ascending size set in yellow gold above a solid gold gemstone ring and two diamond dusted curve bands.
A pear shaped ring with a black rutilated quartz center stone set in yellow gold on a light-complextion ring finger with stacked chevron bands.
A band with white diamonds in ascending size set in yellow gold above a solitaire white diamond engagement ring and two diamond dusted curve bands.

Celestine Tiara Band

14k Gold & White Diamonds

$1,850.00

A ring with a hexagonal shaped white diamond center stone with one baguette white diamond and one white diamond trillion on either side set in yellow gold.
Side view of a ring with a hexagonal shaped white diamond center stone with one baguette white diamond and one white diamond trillion on either side set in yellow gold.

Theda Hex Ring

Yellow Gold & Yellow Diamond (1.57ct)

A three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape yellow diamond center stone surrounded by a lab white diamond with two lab white diamond trillion side stones set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold
Side view of a three stone engagement ring with an marquise shape black diamond center stone surrounded by a white diamond pave halo with two white diamond trillion side stones set in yellow gold.

Marquise Bea Halo Ring

14k Gold & Black Diamond (13x6.5mm)

$9,300.00

A three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape champagne diamond center stone surrounded by a white diamond pave halo with two white diamond trillion side stones set in yellow gold.
Angled view of a three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape champagne diamond center stone surrounded by a white diamond pave halo with two white diamond trillion side stones set in yellow gold.
Side view of a three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape champagne diamond center stone surrounded by a white diamond pave halo with two white diamond trillion side stones set in yellow gold.
A three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape champagne diamond center stone surrounded by a white diamond pave halo with two white diamond trillion side stones set in yellow gold on a ring finger with a diamond dusted straight bands on the pointer finger.

Marquise Bea Halo Ring

14k Yellow Gold & Champagne Diamond (2.11ct)

A curved band with three round white diamonds on either side of a marquise black diamond set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold

Marquise Tiara Band

14k Gold & Black Diamond

$2,300.00

A three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape 1.50ct grey diamond center stone with two white diamond trillion side stones set in rose gold., Rose Gold
Side view of a three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape 1.50ct grey diamond center stone with two white diamond trillion side stones set in rose gold., Rose Gold
A three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape grey diamond center stone with two white diamond trillion side stones set in rose gold stacked above a diamond dusted chrysalis shaped band on a light-complexion left hand., White Gold, Rose Gold, Yellow Gold

Marquise Bea Ring

14k Gold & Grey Diamond (1.50ct)

$9,100.00

A band with 9 round white diamonds set in rose gold., Rose Gold

Chevron Band

14k Gold & White Diamonds

$1,550.00

Most Loved

A band with alternating emerald and baguette cut white diamonds set in yellow gold.
Angled view of a band with alternating emerald and baguette cut white diamonds set in yellow gold.

Theda Band

Yellow Gold & White Diamond

$20,000.00

Best Seller

A band with round grey diamonds in a 3/4 pave around a yellow gold band with white diamond accents on both top and bottom., Yellow Gold
Angled view of a band with round grey diamonds in a 3/4 pave around a yellow gold band with white diamond accents on both top and bottom.
A band with round grey diamonds in a 3/4 pave around a yellow gold band with white diamond accents on both top and bottom on a dark-complexion ring finger.
Two solid gold wedding bands one in white gold engraved with “Diamond” on the inside and one in yellow gold with “Moon + Stars” engraved on the inside.

Celestine Half Eternity Pavé Band

14k Gold & Grey Diamonds

starting at $4,500.00

ADD SPARKLE TO YOUR INBOX

Get exclusive access to events, promotions, and one-of-a-kind fine jewelry drops.

Best Seller

A solitaire round 1.00ct grey diamond ring with double claw prongs set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold
Side view of a solitaire round 1.00ct grey diamond ring with double claw prongs set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold
A solitaire round 1.00ct galaxy grey diamond ring with double claw prongs with white diamond pave on the band set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold

Eleonore Delicate Ring

14k Gold & Grey Diamond (1.00ct)

starting at $5,400.00

A solitaire ring with a round galaxy grey diamond with white diamond pave on either side set in rose gold set beneath two white diamond bands one with marquise diamonds and a crescent shaped band.
A solitaire ring with a round galaxy grey diamond with white diamond pave on either side set in yellow gold set beneath two chevron shaped bands one with grey diamonds.

Hazeline Suite No. 04

starting at $8,830.00

An east/west solitaire ring with a brilliant cut white diamond stone set in yellow gold and inbetween a marquise diamond band and scalloped white diamond band.
An east/west solitaire ring with an oval shape white diamond stone set in yellow gold above a asymmetrical white diamond curve band.
An east/west solitaire ring with an oval shape white diamond stone set in yellow gold set above a 5 white diamond curve band.

Bea Suite No. 20

starting at $20,655.00

An east/west solitaire ring with an oval grey diamond stone set in yellow gold.
A side view of an east/west solitaire ring with an oval grey diamond stone set in yellow gold.

Bea East/West Solitaire Ring

14k Gold & Grey Diamond (1.50ct)

$5,600.00

One-Of-A-Kind

A solitaire ring with a cushion cut grey diamond with double claw prongs set in a knife edge rose gold band.
Angled view of a solitaire ring with a cushion cut grey diamond with double claw prongs set in a knife edge rose gold band.
Side view of a solitaire ring with a cushion cut grey diamond with double claw prongs set in a knife edge rose gold band.

Hazeline Knife Edge Solitaire Ring

Rose Gold & Grey Diamond (1.52ct)

A solitaire round grey diamond ring with double claw prongs with white diamond pave on the band set in rose gold.
Angled view of a solitaire round grey diamond ring with double claw prongs with white diamond pave on the band set in rose gold.
Side view of a solitaire round grey diamond ring with double claw prongs with white diamond pave on the band set in rose gold.

Eleonore Delicate Pave Ring

Rose Gold & Grey Diamond (1.54ct)

$6,900.00

Select Options Ready to Ship
A round rose cut bezel set grey diamond set in white gold., White Gold
A round rose cut bezel set grey diamond set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold
Side view of a round rose cut bezel set grey diamond set in yellow gold.
A round rose cut bezel set grey diamond set in rose gold., Rose Gold

Round Bezel Rosette Ring

14k Gold & Rose Cut Grey Diamond (.60ct)

A cluster engagement ring with a rose cut grey diamond center stone and round grey diamond stones surrounding it set in yellow gold.
Side view of a cluster engagement ring with a rose cut grey diamond center stone and round grey diamond stones surrounding it set in yellow gold.

Petite Celestine Ring

Yellow Gold & Grey Diamonds (.38ct)

A three stone engagement ring with a round shape grey diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in a rose gold band above a pearl and white diamond band.
A three stone engagement ring with a round shape grey diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in a rose gold band inbetween a white diamond dusted curve band and a pearl and white diamond band.

Hazeline Suite No. 26

starting at $8,330.00

A three stone engagement ring with a round shape grey diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in a rose gold band., Rose Gold
Side view of a three stone engagement ring with a round shape grey diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in a rose gold band., Rose Gold
A three stone engagement ring with a round shape white diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in yellow gold stacked above a 7 diamond curve band on a lighter-complexion left hand ring finger., White Gold, Rose Gold, Yellow Gold

Hazeline Three Stone Ring

14k Gold & Grey Diamond (1.00ct)

$5,780.00

A solitaire ring north/south oval white diamond set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold
A side view of a solitaire ring oval grey diamond set in yellow gold.

Bea Solitaire Ring

Yellow Gold & Grey Diamond (1.88ct)

one-of-a-kind

A three stone engagement ring with a cushion cut grey diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in rose gold.
Angled view of a three stone engagement ring with a cushion cut grey diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in rose gold.
Side view of a three stone engagement ring with a cushion cut grey diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in rose gold.

Eleonore Three Stone Ring

Rose Gold & Grey Diamond (2.23ct)

$15,000.00

Select Options Ready to Ship
A curved 11 grey diamond band set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold
Angled view of a curved 11 grey diamond band set in yellow gold.

Tiara Curve Band

14k Gold & Grey Diamonds

$1,700.00

Select Options Ready to Ship
A ring with an oval shaped grey diamond center stone with two round white diamonds on either side set in rose gold.
Angled view of a ring with an oval shaped grey diamond center stone with two round white diamonds on either side set in rose gold.
Side view of a ring with an oval shaped grey diamond center stone with two round white diamonds on either side set in rose gold.

Bea Five Stone Ring

Rose Gold, Grey Diamond (0.95ct) & White Diamonds

A solitaire ring with a round grey diamond with white diamond pave on either side set in white gold inbetween a marquise white diamond band and an 11 white diamond curve band.

Hazeline Suite No. 35

starting at $11,670.00

Best Seller

A solitaire ring with a round black diamond with white diamond pave on either side set in yellow gold.
Side view of a solitaire ring with a round black diamond with white diamond pave on either side set in yellow gold.
A solitaire ring with a round black diamond with white diamond pave on either side set in yellow gold stacked with two diamond curved bands one with white diamonds and black diamonds on medium-complextion on ring finger.

Hazeline Solitaire Ring

Yellow Gold & Black Diamond (.50ct)

$3,350.00

Best Seller

A three stone engagement ring with a round shape black diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold

Hazeline Three Stone Ring

14k Gold & Black Diamond (1.00ct)

$5,450.00

A three stone engagement ring with a round shape black diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in rose gold stacked above a small 7 white diamond curve band in rose gold.

Hazeline Suite No. 11

starting at $6,600.00

A three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape brilliant cut 1.00ct white diamond center stone with two white diamond trillion side stones set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold

Marquise Bea Ring

14k Gold & White Diamond

starting at $12,050.00

A ring with a hexagonal shaped black diamond center stone with one baguette black diamond and one white diamond trillion on either side set in yellow gold.

Theda Hex Ring

Yellow Gold & Black Diamond & Grey Diamond (3.13ct)

Most Loved

A three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape 1.25ct black diamond center stone with two white diamond trillion side stones set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold

Marquise Bea Ring

14k Gold & Black Diamond (1.25ct)

$6,100.00

A band with white diamonds in ascending size set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold

Celestine Tiara Band

14k Gold & White Diamonds

$1,850.00

A ring with a hexagonal shaped white diamond center stone with one baguette white diamond and one white diamond trillion on either side set in yellow gold.

Theda Hex Ring

Yellow Gold & Yellow Diamond (1.57ct)

A three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape yellow diamond center stone surrounded by a lab white diamond with two lab white diamond trillion side stones set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold

Marquise Bea Halo Ring

14k Gold & Black Diamond (13x6.5mm)

$9,300.00

A three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape champagne diamond center stone surrounded by a white diamond pave halo with two white diamond trillion side stones set in yellow gold.

Marquise Bea Halo Ring

14k Yellow Gold & Champagne Diamond (2.11ct)

A curved band with three round white diamonds on either side of a marquise black diamond set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold

Marquise Tiara Band

14k Gold & Black Diamond

$2,300.00

A three stone engagement ring with a marquise shape 1.50ct grey diamond center stone with two white diamond trillion side stones set in rose gold., Rose Gold

Marquise Bea Ring

14k Gold & Grey Diamond (1.50ct)

$9,100.00

A band with 9 round white diamonds set in rose gold., Rose Gold

Chevron Band

14k Gold & White Diamonds

$1,550.00

Most Loved

A band with alternating emerald and baguette cut white diamonds set in yellow gold.

Theda Band

Yellow Gold & White Diamond

$20,000.00

Best Seller

A band with round grey diamonds in a 3/4 pave around a yellow gold band with white diamond accents on both top and bottom., Yellow Gold

Celestine Half Eternity Pavé Band

14k Gold & Grey Diamonds

starting at $4,500.00

ADD SPARKLE TO YOUR INBOX

Get exclusive access to events, promotions, and one-of-a-kind fine jewelry drops.

Best Seller

A solitaire round 1.00ct grey diamond ring with double claw prongs set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold

Eleonore Delicate Ring

14k Gold & Grey Diamond (1.00ct)

starting at $5,400.00

A solitaire ring with a round galaxy grey diamond with white diamond pave on either side set in rose gold set beneath two white diamond bands one with marquise diamonds and a crescent shaped band.

Hazeline Suite No. 04

starting at $8,830.00

An east/west solitaire ring with a brilliant cut white diamond stone set in yellow gold and inbetween a marquise diamond band and scalloped white diamond band.

Bea Suite No. 20

starting at $20,655.00

An east/west solitaire ring with an oval grey diamond stone set in yellow gold.

Bea East/West Solitaire Ring

14k Gold & Grey Diamond (1.50ct)

$5,600.00

One-Of-A-Kind

A solitaire ring with a cushion cut grey diamond with double claw prongs set in a knife edge rose gold band.

Hazeline Knife Edge Solitaire Ring

Rose Gold & Grey Diamond (1.52ct)

A solitaire round grey diamond ring with double claw prongs with white diamond pave on the band set in rose gold.

Eleonore Delicate Pave Ring

Rose Gold & Grey Diamond (1.54ct)

$6,900.00

A round rose cut bezel set grey diamond set in white gold., White Gold

Round Bezel Rosette Ring

14k Gold & Rose Cut Grey Diamond (.60ct)

A cluster engagement ring with a rose cut grey diamond center stone and round grey diamond stones surrounding it set in yellow gold.

Petite Celestine Ring

Yellow Gold & Grey Diamonds (.38ct)

A three stone engagement ring with a round shape grey diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in a rose gold band above a pearl and white diamond band.

Hazeline Suite No. 26

starting at $8,330.00

A three stone engagement ring with a round shape grey diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in a rose gold band., Rose Gold

Hazeline Three Stone Ring

14k Gold & Grey Diamond (1.00ct)

$5,780.00

A solitaire ring north/south oval white diamond set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold

Bea Solitaire Ring

Yellow Gold & Grey Diamond (1.88ct)

one-of-a-kind

A three stone engagement ring with a cushion cut grey diamond center stone with two white diamond round side stones set in rose gold.

Eleonore Three Stone Ring

Rose Gold & Grey Diamond (2.23ct)

$15,000.00

A curved 11 grey diamond band set in yellow gold., Yellow Gold

Tiara Curve Band

14k Gold & Grey Diamonds

$1,700.00

A ring with an oval shaped grey diamond center stone with two round white diamonds on either side set in rose gold.

Bea Five Stone Ring

Rose Gold, Grey Diamond (0.95ct) & White Diamonds

A solitaire ring with a round grey diamond with white diamond pave on either side set in white gold inbetween a marquise white diamond band and an 11 white diamond curve band.

Hazeline Suite No. 35

starting at $11,670.00

Best Seller

A solitaire ring with a round black diamond with white diamond pave on either side set in yellow gold.

Hazeline Solitaire Ring

Yellow Gold & Black Diamond (.50ct)

$3,350.00

Nontraditional Engagement Rings

Ready to say "I do" to a ring from Anna Sheffield? Our one-of-a-kind engagement rings include a variety of silhouettes and glittering diamond cuts, including marquise, round, and more. Choose a ring with a unique and rare center stone or one that features a cluster of diamonds — go beyond the norm and create the ring of your dreams. Our unique engagement rings are also available in your choice of metal from yellow, white, and rose gold, as well as platinum upgrades. Explore our collection and select a stunning piece that’s unmistakably Anna Sheffield.

Nontraditional Engagement Rings

Ready to say "I do" to a ring from Anna Sheffield? Our one-of-a-kind engagement rings include a variety of silhouettes and glittering diamond cuts, including marquise, round, and more. Choose a ring with a unique and rare center stone or one that features a cluster of diamonds — go beyond the norm and create the ring of your dreams. Our unique engagement rings are also available in your choice of metal from yellow, white, and rose gold, as well as platinum upgrades. Explore our collection and select a stunning piece that’s unmistakably Anna Sheffield.

contact us

Custom & Bespoke Engagement Rings

Whether you have a specific ring, stone, or price preference in mind, get in touch with our experts to learn more about Bespoke & Custom engagement rings, made for telling your unique love story.
Learn More >

contact us

Custom & Bespoke Engagement Rings

Whether you have a specific ring, stone, or price preference in mind, get in touch with our experts to learn more about Bespoke & Custom engagement rings, made for telling your unique love story.
Learn More >

FAQs

VIEW MORE FAQS

FAQs

VIEW MORE FAQS